Doris, on Esther's birthday, had planned a celebratory dinner, as she invited Justin in The One I Never Forget Episode 9. With Justin rejecting Doris' invite, she went on to blame Sofia’s return for her son's decision. Not caring about Justin's feelings or how he wasn't in love with Esther, Doris demanded he go out with Esther, a patient girl she had chosen. Would Justin give in?