Turns out, the man is indeed Rhett Callahan and he’s skeptical about Natalie. She explains everything in In Love With a Single-Farmer Daddy Episode 3 and Rhett seems convinced. They travel back to his house with Natalie sitting on his lap. As they fight a seductive staring contest, Ellie—Rhett’s daughter—gets bullied. Will Natalie and Rhett arrive just in time to stop it?