The Fear Street series is one of the highly popular horror/thriller movies. From exploring the small-town drama to witchcraft and suspense following the brutal killings, the Fear Street movies gave a modern touch to horror while feeling nostalgic at the same time.
ReelShort offers a wide range of movies, including suspense thrillers and horror/scary films. We have picked the top 3 similar movies to enjoy if you’re a fan of Fear Street. So stay along!
- Part 1. What Is The Main Story of Fear Street?
- Part 2. 3 Movies like Fear Street on ReelShort
- Part 3. Why You Should Watch Similar Movies like Fear Street on ReelShort?
- Part 4. Conclusion
Part 1. What Is The Main Story of Fear Street?
Fear Street is a horror film series that was released in the year 2021 in a three-part series, and the fourth installment of the movie series was released in 2025. Here’s the storyline breakdown of each Fear Street series to uncover more.
Fear Street Part One: 1994
The first part of the Fear Street series is directed by Leigh Janiak and is based on R. L. Stone’s novel that is titled the same. This horror thriller stars Kiana Madeira, Julia Rehwald, and Olivia Scott Welch in the leading roles.
The story is set in Shadyside, the murder capital of the US. The movie opens with the chilling killings of bookstore worker Heather and six other mall workers who are killed by Heather’s boyfriend, Ryan. But the people of Shadyside believe the killings are because of a witch named Sarah Fier’s curse and that Ryan was possessed by the witch.
But the group of teenagers who don’t believe in the witch’s curse accidentally encounter the brutal killings. The plot escalates when the teens have to survive the night of horror and find out who the killer is.
Fear Street Part Two: 1978
The second installment of the Fear Street movie series features Sadie Sink, Emily Rudd, and Ryan Simpkins. The story in Part Two of Fear Street is set in the summer at Shadyside, where another possessed killer starts brutal killings as the fight for survival continues.
Fear Street Part Three: 1666
The third series of Fear Street, featuring Kiana Madeira, Elizabeth Scopel, and Gillian Jacobs, follows the events of 1666 and 1994 as we are introduced to Sarah Fier, the witch whose curse had been explored in the first installment of the movie.
From following the murder of Sarah Fier to the origin of her curse, this series highlights how the Goode family is responsible for the Shadyside Curse.
Fear Street: Prom Queen
This Fear Street series film is directed by Matt Palmer and features India Fowler, Chris Klein, and David Iacono. This film is based on R.L. Stone’s novel titled The Prom Queen. Unlike the previous three series, this installment in the Fear Street movie holds a standalone storyline.
The plot is set in 1988, and it revolves around the senior class of Shadyside High School. Preparing for the prom, Lori, a student outcast given rumors about her father’s death, signed up for prom queen against the IT girl group who’s called the Wolfpack.
But the excitement of prom soon shifts when one of the girl candidates for prom queen is found murdered by a masked killer. The killings continue as the girls contesting for prom queen start to die one by one.
As Lori tries to warn the school about the murders, she’s crowned the prom queen. But when the killer arrives, continuing the killings, Lori has to find a way to stop the killer and unmask them. But the plot takes a twist when a second killer arrives.
Part 2. 3 Movies like Fear Street on ReelShort
2.1 The Last Onmyoji
If you’re intrigued about Sarah Fier’s curse and want to explore more similar dark horror stories, then you need to check out The Last Onmyoji on ReelShort. This horror thriller movie follows a girl named Dragon, who was called a monster after her birth. From losing her mother to her childbirth, Dragon was considered a freak and unfortunate. Her grandmother rejected her, calling her a jinx.
Nineteen years later, Dragon was all grown up. But her identity as a hermaphrodite is kept hidden as she’s raised by an Onmyoji master. With her innate powers attracting the dark forces, Dragon faced numerous supernatural trials before establishing herself as the final Onmyoji master.
2.2 Look Into My Eyes
Next up we have Look Into My Eyes, a thrilling modern horror series. The first in the anthology series is titled Unwelcome Strangers. Featuring Mariya Stopnyk and Oleksandra Soroka, this series follows two beautiful but helpless-looking girls going and knocking on the victim, a helpful husband’s, door, seeking help with their broken-down car.
The husband saw the helpless girls with their phones empty and car broken and offered them help by inviting them inside his home with an offer to call a tow truck. But soon the girls start to show odd behavior, and things only escalate despite the man’s attempts to pacify the situation. The husband soon realizes the reason he and his house were the crazy girls’s targets as he begins to subdue them.
The second part of the Look Into My Eyes series is titled Pornshoot Went Wrong. The story follows a lonely man who, while looking for a temporary fix to meet his sexual needs, offers a passerby woman to pay for companionship. But soon he found himself trapped with him, fighting for survival.
The third part of the Looking into My Eyes series is called My Naughty Bae, which follows the rich kid who found himself helping a distraught woman who came banging on his car’s window, seeking help. Wanting to play a hero, the rich dude welcomed the woman without realizing his actions of kindness were soon going to have him question his sanity and morality.
Looking Into My Eyes, a trilogy of chilling horror thriller stories, is suspenseful and scary and is very similar to the Fear Street movies. So don’t forget to watch it on ReelShort.
2.3 I Am Bloody Mary
Mary Mitchell is engaged to Nick Thornwood. But Nick, coming from a mysterious family, had no intentions of introducing his fiancé to his family. Despite being curious to know why Mary respected Nick’s choice to maintain secrecy about his family background, soon things changed when Nick’s mother made an unexpected visit and invited Mary to the Thornwood estate to get to know her better. Despite Nick’s fear and anxiousness, Mary insisted on going.
At Thornwood Estate, Mary was dragged into the sinister tradition of the Thornwood family’s rituals, which questioned if Mary could survive the horror that she had walked into.
I Am Bloody Mary is a perfect horror drama similar to Fear Street. You can enjoy this vertical drama on ReelShort.
Part 3. Why You Should Watch Similar Movies like Fear Street on ReelShort?
Horror movies are best experienced and enjoyed when they’re presented visually great. It’s not chilling if the movie fails to draw your attention, instill fear, and play with your curiosity.
The reason the Fear Street series rose to popularity is because of how the series was able to connect to the viewers and keep them hooked with each installment, and perfect cast performances fueled the anticipation and success.
If you’re looking for similar films like Fear Street, then ReelShort should be your go-to pick. ReelShort movies are visually stunning; the screenplay, the acting, and the pacing of the movies are brilliantly done.
The best part about ReelShort is that its vertical format movies can be enjoyed anywhere and everywhere by just downloading the ReelShort app. Unlike other platforms, ReelShort movies come with free previews to give you exclusive glimpses, and you can earn rewards to unlock your favorite movies for free. So download the app and get started.
Part 4. Conclusion
One of the exciting genres in movies is horror. The fear and anticipation of thrill horror movies, when best done, create a euphoric high viewing experience.
One of the popular horror movies is Fear Street, a trilogy followed by a standalone installment that premiered in 2021 and created a new wave in horror thriller movies. The fourth installment of Fear Street was released in 2025. The excitement and anticipation were real to experience the old town killings/survival film.
If you’re a horror fan and love to enjoy the scary thrillers, then you need to check out ReelShort. It’s a vertical movie platform that is known for its range of movies in vertical format and for its visual quality.
Now that we have picked the best three horror movies to stream on ReelShort, don’t forget to check them out.
