If you’re searching for movies like Shutter Island, then you know the thrill of psychological twists.
These kinds of films grip you with suspense, lure you into solving their mysteries, and leave you questioning what’s real. ReelShort brings you the best alternatives for fans of this genre.
Before we dive into our list, let’s see what makes Shutter Island such an unforgettable masterpiece.
- Part 1: What Is The Main Story of the Shutter Island?
- Part 2: 3 Movies Like Shutter Island on ReelShort
- Part 3: What Similar Movies Like Shutter Island Can ReelShort Offer?
- Part 4: Conclusion
Part 1: What Is The Main Story of the Shutter Island?
Films like Shutter Island are not easy to find. But here on ReelShort, we can offer you the best alternatives to the plot you crave. Whether it’s from a movie or a book, we got it all.
But before we feast our eyes on our recommendation list, let’s first see what Shutter Island can offer us!
Shutter Island is a psychological suspense movie directed by Martin Scorsese. It was adapted from a book, and the protagonist was played by Leonardo DiCaprio. It follows the story of Marshal Teddy and his partner Chuck Aule who travelled to Shutter Island.
Marshal Teddy Daniels and his new partner Chuck Aule travel to Shutter Island, home to Ashecliffe Hospital for the criminally insane. They were there to investigate the disappearance of patient Rachel Solando, who was committed for drowning her three children.
But as he stayed on the island, he experienced disturbing visions of his late wife Dolores.
Dolores was killed in a fire set by arsonist Andrew Laeddis. Teddy swore to find him and take revenge. He also has nightmares of children and haunting clues that seem to suggest a larger conspiracy. Teddy suspected unethical experiments on patients and believed the hospital hides a sinister truth.
It was later revealed that Teddy was actually Andrew Laeddis himself. He was admitted at Ashecliffe after murdering his wife Dolores. Another revelation sent the viewers to shock when he recounted the reason for his murder.
Dolores was actually the one who drowned their three children. And everything Andrew was experiencing was a real experiment, a role-play therapy to bring him back to reality and avoid performing lobotomy on him.
In the final scene, Andrew appeared lucid and asked a cryptic question, implying he may be faking the disillusion.
This film has a mind-bending twist that is hard to replicate. But worry not, we have films similar to Shutter Island!
Part 2: 3 Movies Like Shutter Island on ReelShort
Looking for movies like Shutter Island? You’re in the right place! ReelShort has compiled a list of Shutter Island type movies just for you!
2.1 Her Secret Crusader
Her Secret Crusader is a ReelShort action series featuring terrorists and vigilantes. It revolves around the theme of hero saving the world and betrayal. The story starts with the whole town celebrating Lyndon.
He was awarded as the city’s hero and was offered a post in the police. However, he rejected everything and chose to hide his identity. He doesn’t need fame and wealth. All he wanted is to protect his girlfriend, Tatiana by hiding his real identity.
Years passed by and the city procured. But their peace didn’t last long when the terrorist group, Sewer Rats, caused chaos in the city. Their target is the mayor and his daughter. Lyndon also discovered Tatiana’s betrayal.
Heartbroken, Lyndon once again picked up his gun to defend the city and find Tatiana to settle scores.
This ReelShort series is similar to Shutter Island as both protagonists were betrayed by their other half. If Andrew got his revenge by killing his wife, Lyndon here has yet to settle the debt between him and her ex.
This is Shutter Island with an action flair. So if you’re into fighting scenes, this is the perfect movie alternative for you.
2.2 The Adjuster
The Adjuster is probably one of ReelShort’s movies that has an interesting background story. Remember the medical insurance CEO that was killed last 2024 by what the internet labeled as a hot guy? This movie is inspired by it.
The story revolves around Mateo Leone, a man who lost his younger sister due to the scam of a medical insurance company. Unable to accept her death, he vowed revenge towards the medical insurance capitalists.
Mateo sets out to kill and expose the fraud committed by every single insurance company. People cheered for him, some abhor him. But in the end, did it truly satiate him?
The vertical drama has an interesting take about the case. They didn’t glorify and romanticize the whole case, instead they gave a neutral and balanced point of view in the story. What these fraudsters were doing is bad, but it’s equally wrong to take a life.
The Adjuster is similar to Shutter Island in terms of the act of revenge. Out of love for his children, Andrew killed his wife. For Mateo, he killed the very cause of her sister’s suffering and took the punishment just like Andrew.
2.3 Mother Warrior Unleashed
Another ReelShort drama with Shutter Island type of movie plot is Mother Warrior Unleashed. It is a revenge story of a mother whose daughter was trafficked by the Navarro Cartel.
In order to save her daughter, Ryan Phoenix doesn’t hesitate to kill anyone. She abandoned the simple life and took matters into her own hand. She unleashed her wrath by pursuing the cartel and unaliving its members.
A parent’s wrath is something that no one could calm down. That’s the similarity this series has with Shutter Island. Ryan almost went crazy when she heard the news about her daughter. Not even her former boss could pacify her.
She was willing to risk it all, just like Andrew.
Part 3: What Similar Movies Like Shutter Island Can ReelShort Offer?
How can we refer to a movie as “similar to Shutter Island?” It doesn’t need to follow the same plotline or feature carbon-copy characters—but it should carry the same mind-bending twist.
Films like Shuter Island tap into those delicate issues of mental health and where to draw the line. Here are some ReelShort movies that you might want to check aside from the three we mentioned previously.
Look Into My Eyes
Look Into My Eyes is a ReelShort film anthology that will make you scream and hide under your sheet. It’s a movie that will test your mind and how far you could imagine things.
The series records the final moments of the people who picked up a smartphone. Each one of them has their final moments uploaded on the internet. No one really knows how they died, except for the killer who is still out.
Part 4: Conclusion
If Shutter Island left you stunned with its psychological twists and shocking revelations, then ReelShort’s curated list of movies like Shutter Island will keep you hooked from start to finish.
Each of these vertical dramas offers the same combination of suspense, betrayal, and stakes—whether it’s a lover’s hidden agenda, a revenge mission born from tragedy, or a descent into obsession.
